Country: ישראל

Question:

May I eat matbucha left over from Shabbat together with dairy?

 

Answer:

It is permitted to eat salads left over from Shabbat together with dairy, provided that the salads had designated serving utensils during the meal and the diners did not use their personal eating utensils to take from the salads.

Likewise, even if the salads did not have a designated serving spoon, if no one ate from the salads after the meat dishes were brought to the table, the salads may be eaten together with dairy foods. There is no concern that meat from a dish may have splashed into the salad.

It is important to note that in any case—meaning, even if the salads did not have a designated serving spoon and people ate from them at the table after the meat dishes were served—one should refrain from eating the salads together with dairy. However, one may eat the salads without waiting six hours afterward before eating dairy foods.

Indeed, as an optimal practice, before bringing the meat dishes to the table, one should remove from the table any salad that one intends to eat later with dairy.

With blessings for a good year.

 

Sources and Reasoning:

The Beit Yosef, in Yoreh De’ah, siman 89, cites the Yerushalmi, which states that bread eaten with cheese requires that the remnants of that bread be removed from the table before eating meat at the table. The Beit Yosef further cites the Hagahot Ashiri in the name of the Or Zaru’a, who writes that, as an optimal practice, when one ate cheese and wishes to eat meat, one should remove the bread and “any food that was on the table while he ate the cheese.”

In practice, the Shulchan Aruch rules only in accordance with the Yerushalmi: only the remnants of bread from which one ate together with meat or cheese must be removed from the table before eating dairy at the table. However, regarding ordinary bread or food that was on the table while one ate meat or cheese, but from which one did not eat, the Shulchan Aruch does not mention that it must be removed from the table. Apparently, this is because it is not required by the strict law, but only as an optimal practice.

It is clear that, according to the strict law, there is no need to be concerned that foods on the table came into contact with the meat or dairy that was on the table. Only regarding bread, which is eaten together with the foods on the table, is there a concern according to the strict law that it may have come into contact with the meat or dairy on the table.

Therefore, regarding salads that were on the table during a meat Shabbat meal: if they had a designated serving spoon, there is no concern that they became meat foods. Only if they did not have a designated serving spoon and the diners used their personal eating utensils to take from those salads is there concern that the salads became meat foods.

Nevertheless, as an optimal practice, the Hagahot Ashiri indicates that even food that was on the table together with meat should not be on the table where dairy is eaten.

 

In any event, this applies only to not eating the salads together with dairy. After eating the salads, there is no need to wait six hours, since the custom to wait six hours applies only after eating meat or a meat dish, not after eating food into which meat fat was accidentally mixed, without having been intentionally added in order to impart flavor. This is as written by the Shach in siman 89, se’if katan 19; see also the Be’er Heitev there and the Pitchei Teshuvah, se’if katan 7.

This response was translated automatically from Hebrew and has not yet been reviewed by a person. Therefore, it may contain inaccuracies and should not be considered a definitive reference.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

PLEASE NOTE*

Attention: You should not learn from one case to another, each case must be analyzed individually. Generally speaking, it's always best to have contact with a Rabbi in person, not just virtual contact. Note that where there is a local Rabbi("Mara Deatra"), one should ask him. The answers are under the responsibility of the rabbi who responded, and not under the responsibility of the website and/or the Head of the Institution.

Advertise Here!
All proceeds are sacred To the Birkat Avraham organization. Also excellent charity, Advertising is also profitable for your business.

Didn't find an Answer?

Ask The Rabbi

Share us for friends

Last Articles

You may interested

Smart Search Within the Site ×
Ask us to pray for you!

Contact Us

Office

צור קשר

מזכירות: