הרה"ג מאיר פנחסי
Country: ישראל

Question

Dear Rabbi, every year I am uncertain whether I may stand at attention during the siren on Memorial Day for the fallen soldiers of the IDF, as well as on Holocaust Remembrance Day, or whether this falls under the prohibition of following the customs of the nations?

 

Answer

There is no prohibition against standing at attention when hearing the siren. Rather, stand and recite a chapter of Tehillim or one Mishnah for the elevation of the souls of the fallen and the murdered. May the good Hashem bring our end closer, and may we soon merit the salvation of Hashem.

Sources:

Maran the Shulchan Aruch (Yoreh De’ah 178:1) writes: “One may not follow the customs of the nations, nor wear clothing distinctive to them, nor grow the locks of his head like their locks,” etc. The Rema writes there: “All this applies only to something they practice for the sake of immorality, such as their practice of wearing red garments, or something they observe as a statute and custom that has no reason. But something practiced for a benefit, or done as an expression of honor, or for another reason, is permitted.” His pure source is the responsa of the Maharik (Shoresh 88). Likewise, the Ran explains (first chapter of Avodah Zarah, 11a) that the Torah prohibited only the customs of idolatry, which are vain and meaningless matters and all serve idolatrous worship; but matters that have a reason are permitted. This has been accepted by all the poskim. See also the Beit Yosef (siman 178), who explains that the common practice is to be lenient in these matters because it was understood that the prohibition applies only to the matters mentioned in the Gemara.

It is therefore clear that standing at attention for one minute in memory of the fallen, as well as honor salutes in their memory or in honor of important persons and the like, are practices accepted throughout the world as gestures of respect. I see no prohibition if we adopt them as well, although it may have been better had our society refrained from these practices entirely, for after all, they are essentially trivial and lacking in substance.

If our society were religious, or predominantly religious, it would be proper that during that minute of remembrance, all the people stand and recite one chapter of Tehillim for the souls and memory of the fallen. Then their standing would also have a reason, for whenever a deceased person is mentioned, his soul descends at that time to this world; therefore, it is customary to stand during the memorial prayer for souls as a mark of respect (so writes the sefer Emet LeYaakov Algazi in the name of the Maharadach, who heard this from Mahar”i Molcho, who said it in the name of a great sage proficient in the secrets of Torah). However, since this practice has already been adopted and instituted in our country as well, there is no aspect of prohibition if a person acts accordingly, since it has already been accepted as the manner of honoring the fallen. See also Chazon Ovadia—Avelut, vol. I (Laws of the Cemetery, p. 440), which permits, according to the basic halachah, placing floral wreaths on the grave or coffin of the deceased, and rules that this does not constitute following the customs of the nations. This is also discussed at length in Yabia Omer, vol. III (Yoreh De’ah, siman 24). Likewise, Teshuvot Aseh Lecha Rav, vol. IV (siman 4), concludes regarding this matter that standing during the siren does not constitute the prohibition of “you shall not follow their customs.”

This is especially so if you are in a public place, where continuing to walk could cause a chilul Hashem, conflict, and quarrelling, as unfortunately we have seen. Therefore, stand and recite a chapter of Tehillim or one Mishnah at that time for the elevation of the souls of the deceased.

 

Question: Dear Rabbi, every year I am uncertain whether I may stand at attention during the siren on Memorial Day for the fallen soldiers of the IDF, as well as on Holocaust Remembrance Day, or whether this falls under the prohibition of following the customs of the nations?

 

Answer: There is no prohibition against standing at attention when hearing the siren. Rather, stand and recite a chapter of Tehillim or one Mishnah for the elevation of the souls of the fallen and the murdered. May the good Hashem bring our end closer, and may we soon merit the salvation of Hashem.

Sources:

Maran the Shulchan Aruch (Yoreh De’ah 178:1) writes: “One may not follow the customs of the nations, nor wear clothing distinctive to them, nor grow the locks of his head like their locks,” etc. The Rema writes there: “All this applies only to something they practice for the sake of immorality, such as their practice of wearing red garments, or something they observe as a statute and custom that has no reason. But something practiced for a benefit, or done as an expression of honor, or for another reason, is permitted.” His pure source is the responsa of the Maharik (Shoresh 88). Likewise, the Ran explains (first chapter of Avodah Zarah, 11a) that the Torah prohibited only the customs of idolatry, which are vain and meaningless matters and all serve idolatrous worship; but matters that have a reason are permitted. This has been accepted by all the poskim. See also the Beit Yosef (siman 178), who explains that the common practice is to be lenient in these matters because it was understood that the prohibition applies only to the matters mentioned in the Gemara.

It is therefore clear that standing at attention for one minute in memory of the fallen, as well as honor salutes in their memory or in honor of important persons and the like, are practices accepted throughout the world as gestures of respect. I see no prohibition if we adopt them as well, although it may have been better had our society refrained from these practices entirely, for after all, they are essentially trivial and lacking in substance.

If our society were religious, or predominantly religious, it would be proper that during that minute of remembrance, all the people stand and recite one chapter of Tehillim for the souls and memory of the fallen. Then their standing would also have a reason, for whenever a deceased person is mentioned, his soul descends at that time to this world; therefore, it is customary to stand during the memorial prayer for souls as a mark of respect (so writes the sefer Emet LeYaakov Algazi in the name of the Maharadach, who heard this from Mahar”i Molcho, who said it in the name of a great sage proficient in the secrets of Torah). However, since this practice has already been adopted and instituted in our country as well, there is no aspect of prohibition if a person acts accordingly, since it has already been accepted as the manner of honoring the fallen. See also Chazon Ovadia—Avelut, vol. I (Laws of the Cemetery, p. 440), which permits, according to the basic halachah, placing floral wreaths on the grave or coffin of the deceased, and rules that this does not constitute following the customs of the nations. This is also discussed at length in Yabia Omer, vol. III (Yoreh De’ah, siman 24). Likewise, Teshuvot Aseh Lecha Rav, vol. IV (siman 4), concludes regarding this matter that standing during the siren does not constitute the prohibition of “you shall not follow their customs.”

This is especially so if you are in a public place, where continuing to walk could cause a chilul Hashem, conflict, and quarrelling, as unfortunately we have seen. Therefore, stand and recite a chapter of Tehillim or one Mishnah at that time for the elevation of the souls of the deceased.

 

This response was translated automatically from Hebrew and has not yet been reviewed by a person. Therefore, it may contain inaccuracies and should not be considered a definitive reference.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

PLEASE NOTE*

Attention: You should not learn from one case to another, each case must be analyzed individually. Generally speaking, it's always best to have contact with a Rabbi in person, not just virtual contact. Note that where there is a local Rabbi("Mara Deatra"), one should ask him. The answers are under the responsibility of the rabbi who responded, and not under the responsibility of the website and/or the Head of the Institution.

Advertise Here!
All proceeds are sacred To the Birkat Avraham organization. Also excellent charity, Advertising is also profitable for your business.

Didn't find an Answer?

Ask The Rabbi

Share us for friends

Last Articles

You may interested

Smart Search Within the Site ×
Ask us to pray for you!

Contact Us

Office

צור קשר

מזכירות: