לוגו משיב כהלכה
Country: USA

Question

How do we do teshuva?

Answer

I will start by explaining that the expression “doing teshuva” has two meanings (both are important and related to each other):

  • “Teshuva” in the common sense today refers to a person who did not live according to the laws of the Torah and the commandments, but who, thanks to God, decides to completely change their way of life to become observant.
  • “Teshuva” in the halakhic sense refers to a person who has transgressed a law, even once, and who now regrets their action and wishes to take the necessary steps to correct their mistake.

We will present a response to both aspects of this question: “How do we do techuva?”

 

  1. “Doing teshuva” – in the sense of a person who begins to observe the Torah and the mitzvot

 

Let’s start with the common meaning of the expression “doing teshuva.” This refers to a person who until now lived without observingאדם בצוק ליד ים, עם ידיים פתוחות the laws of the Torah and the mitzvot (generally because they grew up in an environment that did not encourage it), but who has had the chance to discover the light of Judaism and wishes to begin observing the Torah and the mitzvot.

 

So, how do we do that?

In theory, the essential thing is the decision to start, with the help of G-D., to get closer to observing the mitzvot (at one’s own pace, as explained later). In other words, the person wishes to begin observing halakha in all aspects of life. It is good and appropriate to reinforce this decision by pronouncing the formula of acceptance of divine sovereignty:

 

שְׁמַע יִשְׂרָאֵל, יי אֱלֹהֵינוּ, יי אֶחָד:
יי הוּא הָאֱלֹהִים. יי הוּא הָאֱלֹהִים:
יי הוּא הָאֱלֹהִים. יי הוּא הָאֱלֹהִים:
יי מֶלֶךְ. יי מָלָךְ. יי יִמְלֹךְ לְעוֹלָם וָעֶד:
יי מֶלֶךְ. יי מָלָךְ. יי יִמְלֹךְ לְעוֹלָם וָעֶד:

 

Hear Israel, the Lord is our God, the Lord is One:

The Lord is the God. The Lord is God:

The Lord is God. YHWH is the God:

YHWH is King. God reigns. God will reign forever and ever:

G-d is King. G-d reigns. The Lord shall reign forever and ever.

It is therefore essential to commit to learning the laws, because without studying them, it is impossible to apply them.

There you go, now, after this decision, the person is already considered a true ba’al tshuva, and with the help of G-d, they will gradually draw closer to the Creator. However, given that the transition from a free lifestyle to a lifestyle in accordance with halakha requires numerous changes, it is necessary to succeed in this task, and also to ensure that the changes are made appropriately and not distorted (as unfortunately happens), it is important to pay attention to several technical recommendations:

 

The progression in the observance of the Torah and the mitzvot must be gradual!! If a person with a ponytail and kippah rushes to start observing the entire Torah immediately, the person might, G-d forbid, fall back. (This is why, for those who are beginning their path of teshuva, all possible leniencies are applied and no stringencies are imposed, as written in the name of our master, Rabbi Ovadia Yosef, in the book Ma’ayan Omer, vol. 4, § 28).

It is very important that the ba’al tshuva has a qualified haredi rabbi with whom he can consult at every step. And it is important thatאדם עם קוקו וכיפה לומד תורה the connection is personal and not digital.

Please provide the text you would like me to translate. Although it is possible to learn halakha alone from contemporary halakha summary books, there is a great advantage to regular learning in a shiur given by a rabbi knowledgeable in the laws, so that the interpretation is precise.

Please provide the text you would like to have translated. It is also advisable to be invited during Shabbatot to Haredi families (and if he is married, to do so with his wife) to closely observe the desired way of living in all aspects of life, as some things can only be learned through direct experience.

  • It is highly recommended to study in a yeshiva for ba’alei teshuva, as it will provide a more adequate response to the needs mentioned in the three previous points.
  • Finally, one should strive not to remain “isolated” in a place where people do not observe the Torah and the commandments, but as much as possible, move to a place where the Torah and the commandments are observed. And if that is not possible, one should make sure to pray in a minyan at the synagogue and physically attend a Torah class, rather than just watching classes online.
  • At a certain stage, in addition to studying halakha, it is also desirable to study the Gemara, as it is proven that the study of the Talmud helps to “rectify” the path of the ba’al teshuva.

And of course, in addition to the observance of the Torah and the mitzvot in general, at a certain stage, it is recommended to pay attention to observing the stages of “teshuva” in the halakhic sense (but in the case of ba’alei teshuva who have made a transformation in their lives, “teshuva” will not be for a single transgression but for faults in general), and this will be explained now:

 

  1. “To do teshuva” – In the halakhic sense

 

How to return to repentance, in the halakhic sense, for one (or several) transgression(s), that is, what are the steps to “erase” the sin and thus purify the soul and draw closer to the Creator once again? The steps are explained by the Rambam in Laws of Repentance (chapter 2, halakha 2):

And what is repentance? It is when the sinner abandons his sin, distances it from his mind, and decides in his heart not to commit it again, as it is said: ‘Let the disbeliever abandon his path,’ and he must also regret the past, as it is said: ‘For after I repented, I regretted…’. He must confess orally and express the points he has decided in his heart to change.

We will detail the steps mentioned by the Rambam:

1) Abandon of sin (now avoiding committing the transgression)

The first step of repentance is the change in the realm of actual actions, that is, the avoidance of the sin for which one “does teshuva.” The individual must indeed cease committing the wrongful act to be considered in a genuine process of repentance.

And if he does not renounce the sin, even if he performs the other steps of repentance, he is like “a man immersed with an impure creature in his hand” (Talmud Ta’anit 16a and Rambam, there, halakha 3), that is, like someone who performs the necessary action to purify himself, but still holds the cause of his impurity.

 

2) The regret for the sin (or sins) committed in the past.

The sinner must feel sorrow for what he has sinned and for having disobeyed the will of the Creator.

The level of this “sorrow” that is considered repentance is such that in his feeling, if he could go back in time, he would act differently (which is the meaning of “regret”). In any case, the more he feels sorrow for what happened, the deeper the repentance is considered.

 

The third step takes place through the individual’s mouth, and it is called “confession.אברכים עושים ווידוי

Unlike Christianity, the individual does not have to confess before other people, but the confession is made before the Creator. Confession is the moment when the individual expresses in words that they have sinned. Stating the sin with one’s mouth helps the individual to further anchor the awareness of what has been done, and thus their repentance is completed.

The essence of confession lies in uttering the words: “But we have sinned” (or “But I have sinned”), and according to strict law, it is not necessary to specify what he has sinned for, but it is appropriate for him to specify what he has sinned (provided there are no others listening), that is, to say: “But I have sinned and I have done this and that.” (Choulhan ‘Aroukh, O.H. § 607, 2).

It is customary to “strike” (gently) with the hand on the heart at the moment of pronouncing the confession. And this also has a benefit according to the secret meaning of the Torah.

4) Acceptance for the future

The final stage of the process of repentance is at the intellectual level, the stable decision for the future (the personal commitment to transform the abandonment of sin into a permanent achievement). This means that the sinner wholeheartedly accepts never to commit this sin (or these sins) again.

The perfect manner of this acceptance is when God knows that His decision is so strong that He will not sin even if the temptation presents itself in the same way with the same precise conditions (Rambam, there, halakha 2: “And let Him testify, He who knows the secrets, that He will never return to this sin, as it is said: ‘And we will no longer say: ‘Our God’ to the works of our hands…’”).

It should be noted that even if subsequently, the individual “fell” and sinned again with the same sin, this does not prove that their repentance was not complete, because at that moment they may have truly made a firm decision, and nevertheless, they relapsed just like anyone else could, without ever having sinned.

 

Addition on repentance: “Parts of atonement”

It is explained in the Talmud Yoma, page 86a, and in the Rambam, Laws of Repentance, chapter 1, halakha 4:

  • An individual who has transgressed a positive commandment, by returning to repentance (with the mentioned steps), has already had their sins atoned for and is considered completely “pure” of the stains of sin.
  • However, if he has transgressed a negative commandment, repentance alone is not enough for his sin to be atoned (that is, for his soul to be completely “clean” of the spiritual stain of the sin), but he must also (in addition to teshuva) observe the day of Yom Kippur.
  • And if the sin was one punishable by karet or death by the court, even Yom Kippur is not enough, but the Holy One, blessed be He, must send him suffering, and then he will be atoned (that is, in addition to repentance and Yom Kippur).
  • And if sin were a profanation of the divine name, then even suffering is not enough, but it will be atoned for when he leaves this world (of course, suicide is forbidden, but this means that when his time comes, it will be atoned for).
  • And if the sin that the individual has committed is “between man and his fellow,” for example, if he has spoken maliciously about others, then none of the above is sufficient; he will not be atoned until he asks his fellow for forgiveness and he forgives him (Mishna Yoma, chapter 8), and if he has stolen, he must also return the stolen item, and so on for other similar prohibitions.

Additional levels in the “teshuva process”

Everything mentioned above, to establish the definition of “teshuva,” the steps we have discussed (abandonment of sin, regret, confession, and acceptance for the future) are sufficient – this is the structure of “basic” repentance, through which the Holy One, blessed be He, “forgives” the individual, and then the positive commandment of “And you shall return to Hashem your God and listen to His voice” is applied. But beyond that, it is possible to add higher levels in repentance, and the higher the level of repentance, the more his soul will be completely purified and he will draw closer to the Holy One, blessed be He.

In the book Shaarei Teshouva by Rabbeinu Yonah zatsal, in chapter 1, section 9, he elaborates on what contributes to strengthening repentance, such as “yagon” (a deep pain of the heart), “shame” (feeling embarrassed before the Creator for having disobeyed His will), “submission” (feeling a sense of submission before the King of kings), and weeping over sins, etc. – see there in detail.

 

Teshuva out of fear compared to teshuva out of love

Our sages (in Yoma, page 86a) and in several places, distinguish between “repentance out of fear” and “repentance out of love.” Because the motivation for repentance directly influences the level of repentance:

  • Repentance out of fear – it is when the individual returns to repentance because they “fear” the Holy One, blessed be He. This “fear” can be broken down into two levels: a. The fear of punishment, that is to say, he returns to repentance out of fear of knowing that otherwise the Holy One, blessed be He, might punish him. (dans ce monde ou dans le monde futur). b. The fear of greatness, where the individual understands and feels that it is not appropriate to disobey the will of the Holy One, blessed be He, because He is great and exalted.
  • Repentance of love (also called “high repentance”) – the individual returns to repentance because they feel love towards the Holy One, blessed be He, and do not want, so to speak, to disappoint His will.

In the repentance of fear, sin is “erased” from the individual’s soul, but in the repentance of love, sin transforms into a “merit” for the individual, who sanctifies themselves through their repentance.

 

The one who says, “I will sin and I will repent”

It is said in the Mishna Yoma, chapter 8:

“The one who says: I will sin and I will repent, I will sin and I will repent, does not receive the means to repent.” I will sin and Yom Kippur will atone, Yom Kippur does not atone.

This means that an individual who commits a sin, and who plans to repent after the sin in order to escape punishment, our sages testify that he will not succeed in returning to repentance (and there are different interpretations of this and we do not elaborate here).

But if, by mistake, he acted in this manner, if he manages to repent even for that, that he sinned with the intention of repenting (that is, he truly regrets this approach from the beginning, and he would not have wanted to sin even if he had been given the opportunity to repent and escape punishment), then his repentance will be accepted.

 

And to conclude

And to conclude, it is important to know that a penitent should not remain in a state of sadness about the past permanently, because only at the moment of confession should the individual feel pain (as the Arizal wrote), but the rest of the time, they should be in joy, and serve the Holy One, blessed be He, with joy (Deuteronomy 28:47), and rejoice in the fact that they had the chance to return to repentance, and our sages said (Talmud Berakhot, page 34b) that in the place (in paradise) where the penitents stand, the complete righteous cannot stand.

 

Good luck!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

PLEASE NOTE*

Attention: You should not learn from one case to another, each case must be analyzed individually. Generally speaking, it's always best to have contact with a Rabbi in person, not just virtual contact. Note that where there is a local Rabbi("Mara Deatra"), one should ask him. The answers are under the responsibility of the rabbi who responded, and not under the responsibility of the website and/or the Head of the Institution.

Advertise Here!
All proceeds are sacred To the Birkat Avraham organization. Also excellent charity, Advertising is also profitable for your business.

Didn't find an Answer?

Ask The Rabbi

Share us for friends

Last Articles

Contact Us

Office

צור קשר

מזכירות: